The tobacco plantations in Virginia and the sugar plantations in the Caribbean both pre-date the Plymouth colony. Also, both were established as economic/commercial ventures. By the time the Puritans arrived in Plymouth (lost BTW (sort of) they were also headed for Virginia) the population of the Americas by "immigrants" exceeded 1 million.
Most all of those who chose to move to the "New World" did so for the sole purpose of striking it rich. I forsee the same mindset in migration to Mars. The environment is too harsh and unforgiving, and the risk is too great to believe that it will be colonized for any sort social engineering/hippie cults.
That doesn't change the fact that some people moved to the colonies to escape something.
Given that so far there is nothing in space worth colonizing financially, the first colonies might be funded by rich people who want to build their own little utopias.