- Joined
- Feb 6, 2008
- Messages
- 38,965
- Reaction score
- 3,937
- Points
- 203
- Location
- Wolfsburg
- Preferred Pronouns
- Sire
You ignore something important about the difference between an open society and a dictatorship:
The dictator will lie. Its as sure as gravity. In case of North Korea, the lies are even the foundation of the whole state philosophy and person cult.
An open society with freedom of press can't lie as whole. Individuals can lie. But enough will report, what others don't want to be told and will expose lies. Even lies by the government will fail quickly, because the story will be told. You can not stop the signal. Even in a tight-knit society like Israel, people can report what the government does not want to hear.
Sweden looks bad, because everybody in the world can know it. The health care system is very much transparent by having open data interfaces providing you many real-time statistics about its performance and everybody in the world was able to see, how people died. The government was very transparent about its strategy and assumptions and a parliament inquiry provided a lot of criticism in how these assumptions had been wrong and did not get corrected. They did not find that all assumptions had been bad - Sweden still follows a much different approach as the rest of the Scandinavian countries, but it moved much closer to them, adapting it strategy from the opposite direction. Maybe Sweden will be more right about how to handle COVID-19 in 2021. But sure did not perform anyway good in 2020.
In North Korea, we need satellite images of prison camps and mass graves just for at least estimating how many people lived and died there. Because according to its dictatorship, there are no such prison camps and nobody dies. There are reports of 80000 people in quarantine for pneumonia-like symptoms in 2020 - but none of those had COVID-19 par ordre de muft or even the term COVID-19 used in the quarantine orders. A large number of people got tested for something, which might have been COVID-19. But even they never got told, they just got quarantined depending on the results. Still, the official number of COVID-19 cases in North Korea is zero.
One thing is for sure: We will never know, how many people died in North Korea in 2021. Neither of famine. Nor of a pandemic. Because both never happens in North Korea.
The dictator will lie. Its as sure as gravity. In case of North Korea, the lies are even the foundation of the whole state philosophy and person cult.
An open society with freedom of press can't lie as whole. Individuals can lie. But enough will report, what others don't want to be told and will expose lies. Even lies by the government will fail quickly, because the story will be told. You can not stop the signal. Even in a tight-knit society like Israel, people can report what the government does not want to hear.
Sweden looks bad, because everybody in the world can know it. The health care system is very much transparent by having open data interfaces providing you many real-time statistics about its performance and everybody in the world was able to see, how people died. The government was very transparent about its strategy and assumptions and a parliament inquiry provided a lot of criticism in how these assumptions had been wrong and did not get corrected. They did not find that all assumptions had been bad - Sweden still follows a much different approach as the rest of the Scandinavian countries, but it moved much closer to them, adapting it strategy from the opposite direction. Maybe Sweden will be more right about how to handle COVID-19 in 2021. But sure did not perform anyway good in 2020.
In North Korea, we need satellite images of prison camps and mass graves just for at least estimating how many people lived and died there. Because according to its dictatorship, there are no such prison camps and nobody dies. There are reports of 80000 people in quarantine for pneumonia-like symptoms in 2020 - but none of those had COVID-19 par ordre de muft or even the term COVID-19 used in the quarantine orders. A large number of people got tested for something, which might have been COVID-19. But even they never got told, they just got quarantined depending on the results. Still, the official number of COVID-19 cases in North Korea is zero.
One thing is for sure: We will never know, how many people died in North Korea in 2021. Neither of famine. Nor of a pandemic. Because both never happens in North Korea.